GOP Speaker defends UK, criticizes Beshear's public complaints over hiring
FRANKFORT, Ky. — A partisan clash over governance at the University of Kentucky escalated Wednesday when the state's Republican House Speaker publicly rebuked Gov. Andy Beshear for his social media criticism of the university's leadership, saying the Democratic governor's public pressure undermines institutional independence.
House Speaker David Osborne said in a statement that he offers "strong support for the University of Kentucky and its current leadership," adding that the governor's Tuesday and Wednesday social media posts criticizing Beshear the appointment of U.S. District Judge Gregory Van Tatenhove as law school dean and a $950,000 post-retirement position for Athletics Director Mitch Barnhart represent "a troubling departure from the restraint that should guide interactions between the executive branch and independent institutions."
Osborne, a UK alumnus, praised President Eli Capilouto's "steady, thoughtful, and solutions-oriented" leadership and defended Van Tatenhove as "widely respected among judicial and legal communities after decades of principled leadership."
Beshear had expressed "growing concern and loss of confidence" in UK management, contending that Van Tatenhove was the only candidate not recommended by law school faculty and that these decisions appeared "related to certain donors pushing partisan and undue outside influence onto the university." Van Tatenhove has deep ties to coal executive Joe Craft and his wife Kelly Craft, major GOP donors to the university, according to federal disclosures.
The dispute centers on whether independent universities should face public executive pressure over governance decisions. Republican Secretary of State Michael Adams also pushed back at Beshear's criticism, while law school namesake J. David Rosenberg defended Van Tatenhove's qualifications.
Barnhart ultimately decided not to take the post-retirement position after Beshear's complaints, but UK is continuing with Van Tatenhove's appointment despite law faculty opposition. Trustee Jim Gray has proposed establishing a stakeholder group to revise dean selection processes to give the Board of Trustees voting power on such appointments.